Reynold Toepfer was the swashbuckling idol magnet of Caramoan — a salesman and one of the season's "Three Amigos," the Fans trio with Eddie Fox and Malcolm Freberg who refused to go quietly against the Favorites. Reynold had a knack for finding hidden immunity idols and the bravado to wield them, turning himself into the player the Favorites most wanted gone and could never quite catch off guard.
The idol arms race finally caught up with him: outmaneuvered in the cat-and-mouse over who was holding what, he was voted out in eighth with the wrong read on the night. A bold, high-variance gunslinger who made the merge must-see television.
