Neal Gottlieb, the founder of an ice cream company, was a sharp strategic force on Kaôh Rōng's Brains tribe who found a hidden immunity idol and looked poised for a deep run. The opposing alliance was so wary of that idol they planned to split votes against him at the first merge Tribal.
They never got the chance: an infection forced the medical team to pull him on Day 19, idol unplayed. He returned as a juror only to make history again — when Michele used a final-challenge advantage to remove a juror, Neal became the first person ever voted off a Survivor jury, denied even a finale vote.












